COAI comes heavily on Tatas

May 14, 2006 · Filed Under Mobile 

COAI has strongly criticized Tata’s stand on the new spectrum policy to which Tatas had filed objections. It is very well known that Tatas first joined the IDEA consortium and then backed out of IDEA when the Ambanis lobbied with late Shri Pramod Mahajan for CDMA technology to join the telecom war using CDMA. Guess strategists and decision makers in the Tata house were a confused lot ;-)

“Tatas first alleged that the subscriber numbers of the other operators were fudged. Now they accede that other operators have a headstart. Strangely, they expect front runners in a fiercely competitive marketplace to stop running in the race so that a laggard (the Tatas) can catch up,” said TV Ramachandran, director general of COAI.

It has been the policy of the government since 2002 that operators with a higher market share need more spectrum. This found favour with all operators including the Tatas. Why this opposition so late in the day? said CEO of a leading Cellco.

Clearly the Tatas are levelling baseless allegations against competitive GSM operators who have revolutionized cell technology in India. The Tatas are a distant second in the CDMA space losing heavily to Reliance Infocom.

Comments

4 Responses to “COAI comes heavily on Tatas”

  1. Chetan on May 22nd, 2006 9:13 am

    More on Spectrum is available at the following link http://www.financialexpress.com/fe_full_story.php?content_id=127895

  2. Convergence India » Blog Archive » Indian Bandwidth Prices to Crash ? on May 27th, 2006 6:38 am

    [...] The International court of Arbitration today ruled in favour of Reliance Telecom, who owns and controls international carrier Flag Telecom. Flag Telecom’s landing station in India are under the control of Tata’s owned VSNL. VSNL refused to give access to Reliance Infocomm thus creating a monopoly to carry international traffic. Lately, Tata’s have been behaving very incompetently especially with their telecom ventures. Soon after the ruling, BPO companies in Guragon and Bangalore were cheering as they are expecting to get more bandwidth at cheaper prices. Cheers to International court of arbitration [...]

  3. Convergence India » Blog Archive » Ratan Tata’s acqusition on subscriber number authenticty gets a blow. on May 31st, 2006 4:02 am

    [...] ET & PTI report that TRAI chairman, Nripendra Misra has confirmed that the figuers of subscribers released by cellcos are authentic. Earlier Tata group chairman Ratan Tata had questioned the authenticity of subscriber numbers released by cellcos on which they are eligible for further spectrum according to TRAI and DoT spectrum allocation policy. “The figures announced by mobile operators every month are correct and authentic.” said Misra [...]

  4. » Why is Ratan Tata opposed to all other operators ? :: Broadband in India :: on November 15th, 2006 6:26 pm

    [...] I am a bit curious to know why is Ratan Tata opposing the COAI / Association of Telecom service providers ? He is in battle against COAI and the ministry since May this year. He first accused that mobile service providers cooked up their subscriber figures which was stronly criticized by the COAI. COAI in a statement said, They expect front runners in a fiercely competitive marketplace to stop running in the race so that a laggard (the Tatas) can catch up. [...]

Leave a Reply




Poll